Because
there is no review process or regulation for the public Web, you will need
to judge for yourself the quality of the material you find. Keep in mind
these questions: |
Relevancy
/Coverage |
-
Does the article address the topic?
- Does it provide
you with the type of information needed? (e.g. background information,
history, statistical data, analysis, studies or experiments)
- How general or
specific is the information about the topic?
- Does the information
you retrieve need to be recent, and if so, does the article provide recent
information? |
Authorship
/ Source |
-
Is the article from a major newspaper, an established, reputable magazine,
or a scholarly journal (in other words, a reliable source)?
- Does it list an
author or is the article unsigned?
- Is this article
sponsored by an organization or lobbying group? |
Language
Level / Intended Audience |
-
Is the language simple and conversational or is the language complex and
sophisticated?
- Is the language
of this article written at a scholarly level?
- Who is the intended
reader of this article?
- Is this article
written to grab your attention or is it written in an impersonal, scientific
manner? |
Objectivity
/
Bias |
-
Is there a strong point of view expressed?
- Is the primary
purpose of this article to sway opinion, to inform, to sell something,
or to report facts?
- Is the text substantiated
by facts and evidence or does it only offer opinion? |
Accuracy
or Validity |
-
Is there a bibliography or list of references provided with the article?
If so, scan the list to see the types of sources on which the author has
based his/her work.
- Does the author
present facts in an objective manner and provide a list of references,
or does s/he present an unsupported opinion?
- When you consult
another publication to verify the information presented in this article,
will the facts be substantiated? |